Balance Transfer vs Cash Advance: Which Option Is Right for You?
A balance transfer and a cash advance both involve credit cards. They also offer financial solutions based on what you’re going through. However, even though they may sound similar, there’s a big difference between a balance transfer and a cash advance.
Let’s go through each financial option one by one, including the pros and cons of balance transfer vs cash advance, to help you make the smartest choice for your wallet.
What is a Balance Transfer?
A balance transfer is when you move existing debt, usually from one or more credit cards, to a new credit card that offers a lower interest rate. In many cases, card issuers offer introductory 0% APR rates for balance transfers, which last anywhere from 6 to 21 months. This gives you a window to pay down your debt without accumulating interest, making it easier for you to get ahead.
But balance transfers aren’t free. Most cards charge a balance transfer fee of 3% to 5% of the amount you’re moving. This means if you transfer $5,000, you could pay $150 to $250 in fees upfront. Still, if you’re currently paying double-digit interest rates, the savings can be significant.
People often use balance transfers for three reasons:
- To pay off high‑interest credit card debt faster
- To combine multiple debts into one payment
- To save on interest while paying down the principal
This is a strategy best suited for people who are serious about getting out of debt. If you don’t pay off the balance during the 0% APR period, the regular interest rate that is often between 18% and 25% kicks in, and you could end up right where you started.
For example, say you have $3,000 on a card charging 24% APR. If you keep the debt there and only make minimum payments, you could easily pay over $1,000 in interest in just 18 months. Now, if you transfer that $3,000 to a card offering 0% APR for 18 months with a 3% fee, you’ll pay $90 upfront and no interest if you pay it off within that window.
What is a Cash Advance?
A cash advance lets you borrow cash against your credit card’s available credit limit. Most issuers cap cash advances at a lower sub‑limit, often 20 % to 50 % of your overall line.
It’s convenient and doesn’t require a separate loan application. However, it comes with a price.
Unlike regular purchases on your credit card, cash advances are treated as immediate debt with higher costs and fewer protections.
People turn to cash advances to tackle emergencies, like when rent is due, your car breaks down, or you’re out of options and need cash fast.
They may come with higher APRs than your card’s purchase rate, ranging from 25% to 39%. Interest starts occurring immediately, even if you pay your balance fully by the due date. Most issuers charge a cash advance fee either in the form of a percentage of the amount you borrowed, which falls between 3% and 5%, or a flat rate, whichever is greater. Also, if you use an ATM, you may pay a transaction fee to the ATM provider, adding to the overall cost.
Consider you need $500, and you take it out as a cash advance. Your card charges a 5% fee, so you pay $25 right away. The APR is 28%, and interest starts the same day. If you don’t repay the balance for 30 days, you’ll owe roughly $11.5 in interest. That’s a total of $36.5 just to borrow $500 for a month. Remember, the costs increase the longer you wait to repay it.
Cash Advance vs Balance Transfer: Key Differences
Let’s compare a balance transfer vs a cash advance side by side so you can spot the key differences:
|
Feature |
Balance Transfer |
Cash Advance |
|
Purpose |
Move existing credit card debt |
Access quick cash |
|
Interest rate |
Often 0% to low promotional APR |
Typically high, around 25% to 39% |
|
Fees |
3% to 5% of the transferred amount |
3% to 5% fee or flat rate with possible ATM charges |
|
Interest grace period |
Often includes a 0% intro period |
No grace period |
|
Effect on credit score |
May help if it reduces total utilization |
May hurt if it spikes your credit usage ratio |
|
Speed of access |
Takes a few days to process |
Instant at an ATM or bank |
Is a Balance Transfer a Cash Advance?
No, they are not. A balance transfer moves debt, and a cash advance gives you cash.
Pros and Cons of Each Option
Pros of Balance Transfer
0% Interest Offers Can Save You Hundreds
Many cards offer 0% APR on balance transfers for six to 18 months. That means more of your payment goes toward your actual debt instead of interest. It’s one of the most cost‑effective ways to pay off high‑interest credit card balances.
Debt Consolidation Simplifies Payments
If you’re juggling multiple credit card balances, a transfer lets you combine them into one manageable monthly payment. Fewer due dates, less stress.
May Improve Your Credit Score Over Time
Reducing your credit utilization ratio (the amount of outstanding debt compared to your credit limit) by paying off old cards may improve your credit score.
Cons of Balance Transfer
Transfer Fees Can Eat into Your Savings
Most balance transfers come with a 3% to 5% fee, which can add up, especially for large amounts. So, make sure you calculate whether the interest saved outweighs the fee.
Not Everyone Qualifies for 0% Offers
You usually need to have good to excellent credit to get the best deals. If your score is below 670, your options might be limited or come with shorter promo periods.
Deferred Interest Can Be Risky
Once the 0% period ends, the regular APR kicks in, and it’s often 18% to 25%. If you don’t pay off the full balance by then, interest starts accruing on the remaining amount.
Pros of Cash Advance
Fast Access to Cash When You Need It
Whether it’s an emergency car repair or covering rent, a cash advance puts physical cash in your hands almost instantly. No loan application, no waiting.
No Extra Account Needed
It’s already built into your credit card. There’s no need to apply for a new credit line. This makes it convenient when you’re in a pinch.
Useful When Cards Aren’t Accepted
Some situations, like paying a landlord, covering utility bills, or shopping at cash‑only businesses, require actual cash, and a cash advance can bridge that gap when card payments aren’t an option.
Cons of Cash Advance
Higher Interest Rate
You’ll likely pay high interest rates of around 25% to 29%, no grace period, and a cash advance fee, all at once. Interest rates start immediately, not after your statement date.
Your Credit Score May Take a Hit
Cash advances increase your credit utilization, which can have negative effects on your score. If you don’t manage your debt carefully, it can quickly add up and make things harder to handle.
No Rewards or Purchase Protections
Cash advances generally don’t earn rewards and don’t qualify for purchase‑return chargebacks, but unauthorized use is still covered by zero‑liability policies.
When to Choose a Balance Transfer
A balance transfer creates the opportunity to pay off debt faster and more affordably. So, if you’re dealing with a high‑interest credit card balance and need some breathing room, you may choose a balance transfer. For example, if your current APR is 20% or more, you can save a significant amount in interest if you transfer that debt to a card offering 0% or low interest for a set period.
However, you have to be absolutely confident that you can pay off the debt during the promotional period, if you qualify for it. If you don’t clear the balance before the promotional rate expires, the regular APR can sometimes be higher than what you were paying before.
Also, if you want to simplify your finances with fewer due dates to track and one predictable monthly payment, a balance transfer may work for you.
When to Choose a Cash Advance
A cash advance can be a lifeline in a financial emergency, but it is not meant for everyday expenses or long‑term borrowing. Because of the high fees and immediate interest, it should only be used when you’re out of options and need quick access to cash.
So if you’re facing an urgent expense and don’t have savings or another way to cover it, a cash advance can provide fast relief when you need money immediately and can’t wait for a loan approval. A cash advance through your credit card’s ATM access is one of the quickest ways to get it.
Only get a cash advance when you fully understand the fees and interest, and have a clear plan to repay it within a few days or weeks to keep charges as low as possible.
FAQ
How Long Does a Balance Transfer Take?
It usually takes five to seven business days, but it can also take up to three weeks, depending on the card issuer and the banks involved. Always check with your provider.
Do Balance Transfers Hurt Credit Score?
Applying for a new card prompts a hard inquiry (the issuer pulls your full credit report, often shaving a few points off your score for about a year), and the new account lowers the average age of your credit lines, so you may see a short‑term dip. On the upside, the additional credit limit can shrink your overall utilization ratio; if you keep balances low, your score can rebound and even improve over time.
Can I Balance Transfer a Cash Advance?
If the balance is on your card, you can transfer a cash advance balance to another card offering a lower rate.
Does a Cash Advance Count as a Purchase?
No. That means it usually doesn’t qualify for rewards, grace periods, or promotional APRs.
You may be interested in these blogs, too:
